Tuesday, 4 December 2012

Secondary Research For My Final Idea

"They say that our bodies are our own, and we should be allowed to do what we want with them. So it's wrong to make anyone live longer than they want. In fact making people go on living when they don't want to violates their personal freedom and human rights.It's immoral, they say, to force people to continue living in suffering and pain.
Therefore; if suicide is not a crime, euthanasia should not be a crime."
 .............................................................................................................................................

What is euthanasia?

Euthanasia (also kown by some as mercy killing) basically means to take a deliberate action with the express intention of ending a life to relieve intractable suffereing.

There are three differect types of euthanasia;
1. Voluntary:- This is where the patient gives 100% consent for their death. They get a full say in the matter.
2. Non-Voluntary:- This is where the patient cannot have an input; for example, if brain dead or in a vegetated state; th next of kin will make th decision based on the patients best interest.
3. Involuntary:- This is the type which is otherwise known as murder. This is where the patient has no thought in dying, the act goes against their will, for exampl child euthanasia.

There are two procedural types of euthanasia;
1. Passive:- This is where the life sustaining treatment is withheld; for example, people who have DNR cards (this means do not resuscitate).
2. Active:- This is where lethal substances are used to end the patients life.


What are the methods?

There are four main methods used for euthanasia;
1. Drugs:- The main method used in Switzerland, this is when an oral dose of an aniemic drug is given, follwed approximately 30 seconds after by a lethal ovrdose of powdered pentobarbital dissolved in either water or fruit juice. This overdose depresss the cental nervous system causing respitory arrest.
2. Injcetions:- The main method in the Netherlands, there are two injections, one which send the patient into a coma, then the second is given to stop the heart beating. Sometimes an intavnous potassium chloride is given to hasten cardiac arrest.
3. Starvation and dehydration:- Terminal sedation is mixed with the complete withdrawl of all foods and fluids.
4. Gases, plastic bags and "peaceful pill":- These ar the most used methods in Australia and Nw Zealand. Helium is taken to cause a death by lung failure. The peaceful pill is a barbiturate-based pill.

"If we can get people to except the removal of all treatment especially the removal of food and fluids, they will see what a painful way to die is, and then in the patients best interst, accept the lethal injection" - Dr Helga Kuhse


 

Why is it illegal in the UK?

Euthanasia is currently illegal in Britain. To kill another person deliberately is murder or manslaughter, even if they have asked you to do so. Anyone doing so could fac 14 years in prison. Under the 1961 Suicide Act, it is also a criminal offence to assist, aid or counsel sombody in relation to taking their own life. Nevertheless, the authorities may decid not to prosecute in cases of euthanasia after taking into account the circumstances of death.

The Times (2007) reported by a survey that 80% of the public said they wanted the law changd to giv terminally ill patients the right to die with doctors help. I feel that if people deserve the right to live, they should deserve the right to die.

information from : http://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/euthanasia/overview/problems.shtml

Who would be inetersted in euthanaisa?

The word "euthanasia" litterally means "good death" but now in modern usuag it has come to mean intentional killing.

Terminally ill and incurably disabled people are those most at risk of having their lives deemed "not worth living" whether or not they have asked to be killed. Thes are the people viewed by the pro-ethanasia lobby as being the benficiaries of any law to allow euthanasia. People of vegetated states or are brain dead, as wll as the terminally ill are all people who ar most likely to ask for assisted suicide. However, 20% of the people asking for assistd suice are not ill at all, more just "tired of living"


How far back does it date?
Euthanasia has ben going on for a long time. However the contemory debate on euthanasia started in 1870. Euthanasia was practisd in Ancit Greek as well as strongly opposed in the Judeo-Christian Tradition back in 1565. Religion has always been a factor for this. In th early 1800's Euthanasia techniques such as the morphine overdose was claimed as wrong and therefore starting the debate.

"That in all cases of hopeless and painful illness, it should be the recognised duty of the medical attendant, whenever so desired by th patient, to administer chloroform or such other anaesthetic to destroy the consciousness at once and put the sufferer to a quick and painless death" - Samuel Williams 1872


 The pages below are more research I have done on Euthanasia;

Thursday, 29 November 2012

Initial Ideas Group Talk

My Ideas and Feedback;

Initial Idea 1:


Initial Idea 1 Feedback:


Initial Idea 2:


Initial Idea 2 Feedback:


Initial Idea 3:


Initial Idea 3 Feedback:

Monday, 19 November 2012

Factual Television Production; Initial Ideas

Initial Idea One
Topic:
  • Animal Captivity
Angle:
  • Putting a stop to it
  • Are Zoos good or bad
  • Why do people do it
Documentary Mode:
  • Reflexive
  • This is because i would get involved with th documentary. I would be seen on screen and i would show the audience me 'behind the scenes' so they get more of the truth.
Appeal To Audience:
  • What kind of people are against animal cruelty
  • Animal lovers would be against it
  • Age - any
  • Gender - Male and female
  • Interest - Animals
  • Location - Any
  • Ethnicity - Any
Assumed Knowledge:
  • Expect the audience to know a bit about it to get involved
Key Groups to Interview:
  • Animal lovers
  • Animal rights campaigners
  • animal sheltrs
  • zoo coodinators
Initial Idea Two
 Topic:
  • Unemployment in the UK
Angle:
  • Why so many people are unemployed
  • Are thre enough jobs?
Documentary Mode:
  • Participatory
  • This is becaus i would like there to be a presenter, on screen, as well as trying to make it an unbiased documentay.
Appeal To Audience:
  • Most 16-24 year olds are unemployed
  • Males and Females
  • Quite a large issue with most people
  • Age - 16 - 25 yr olds
  • Gender - Male and female
  • Interest - Finding work
  • Location - Uk
  • Ethnicity - Any
Assumed Knowledge:
  • Very little knowledge as to why this is
Key Groups to Interview:
  • Unemployed people aged 16-24
  • Job managers 
  • Job Centre workers 
Initial Idea Three
 Topic:
  • Euthinasia/Dignitas
Angle:
  • Is it wrong or right
  • More than 'murder'
  • What is it
  • Should it be illegal or not
Documentary Mode:
  • Particapatory/Reflexive
  • This is bcause i would like to get involved myself as i would like to find out som facts as well as show behind the scnes to show the facts are real as well as the places i go to.
Appeal To Audience:
  • Most people have heard of it but dont have knowledge of what it is
  • Have presenter with little knowledge
  • Doesnt apply to a certain type of audience so everyone could be interested
  • Age - 16+
  • Gender - Male and female
  • Interest - Law/politics, Medicine
  • Location - Any
  • Ethnicity - Any
Assumed Knowledge:
  • Almost nothing
  • Heard of it but not know anything - Give them reason to listen
  • Exposition
Key Groups to Interview:
  • Doctors
  • Vox Pops of opinions
  • Family members/nursecare members
  • Court Lawyers

Friday, 16 November 2012

Studio News Conventions

For this task we had to create a video in which we spoke about the conventions of a studio news report. 

In the video we spoke about;

The presenter/news anchor:
- Their costume
- The framing of the shot
- The choice of presenter
- And their body language

Mode Of Address to the Viewer:
- The readers tone of voice
- Their accent
- The language they spoke in
- And their eye contact with the camera/viewer

Interviewing Experts And/Or Witnesses:
- The camera techniques used
- The Location in which we filmed
- The status of the interviewee
- The graphics used
- And the question and answer techniques

We decioded to take the route of a 'mick take' to show the good exmapls and the bad examples of these such conventions.

Documentary Modes

"A Documentaries Primary Function Is To Offer The Audience Information And Put Forward An Argument, To Persuade The Audience To Think In A Certain Way, To Do Something To Accept The Argument. It Achieves This By Presenting The Truth Of It's Argument As Self Evident, Unified and Non-Contradictoy"

There are 5 documentary modes which Bill Nicholls has suggested, each in order of how they shape the truth;

1. Expository (voice of God)
This mode is what we most identify with the documentary; it "emphasizes verbal commentary and argumenative logic" often using a narrator.

March Of The Penguins is a clear example of an expository documentary. This is because the show is a nature documentary and most of these are usually always expository. They take an answer and explore that in one way, assuming a logical argument as well as using direct address. March of the penguins uses this as you never see the presenter, but you always hear him in the voice overs. The presenters do not get involved with the penguins.

     However, some would argue that even though this type of documentary doesnt lie or take opinions, it doesnt show the whole truth.
    - The producers choose what parts to record, as well as it was all planned before they went out and filmed it all.
    - They also choose when to cut the shots and what parts to    put together, then to be released.
Some have argued that this documentary have used animation which also has caused debates on whether this is the whole truth.

The use of narrativisation in this document is very important, as without it we wouldn't have a clue what is going on. There is not much dramatisation in this documentary as its real life, animal documentaries dont use 'drama' as there is usually alot there anyway. This documentary is very real, although arguable.

Having only a voice over on this video helps the audience understand what is going on in the video, what the penguins are doing and why, as the penguins can't tell us. Having a well known voice such as Morgan Freeman would make the audience feel relaxed and pay more attention to what he is saying.

  
2. Observational (window on the world)
This mode is one in which is attempts to capture (as accurately as possible) objective reality with the filmmaker as neutral observer. A real example of 'fly on the wall'.
Geri is an example of this type of documentary because, as it explains above, a fly on the wall. This documentary shows the 'roller-coaster' career of the former Spice Girl, Geri Halliwell. It follows her with very little involvment from the presenter, which makes it an observational documentary. This documentary involves, however, some candid behind the scenes footage of Geri as well as interviews with her.

This documentary would be a form of realism as the presenters show everything about her, although cuting away and not showing everything they film, it doesnt use narration or make it dramatic.

Observational documentaries show the audience what is going on, with no voice over or narration. This would make the audience think that what they are seeing is 100% rreal, which is what the director would have wanted to do. It would make the audience feel more enganged with the programme, however without narration they might not understand some things that are happening.



3.Interactive/Participatory
Unlike observaional, this mode welcomes direct engagement between the filmmaker and the subject. This means the filmmaker becomes part of the events being recorded.
Bowling For Columbine is a good example of the interactive mode. This is because of the way in which it is filmed. Michael Moore doesnt just choose what bits hes going to film and then films it, he specificaly films himself "behind the scenes" walking into shops, etc etc.  This shows the audience what is actually happening, so it shows us more of the truth.

Although showing signs of bias and opinions, more of the truth comes out when he 'investigates'. Michael Moore's documentaries use some forms of narrativisation as well as realism, however, the use of dramatisation isnt usually present as, documentaries like this one, focus on very serious subjects. The use of reconstructions however, may be present.

Having the director become completely involved with the making of the documentary would help the audience believe that the documentary is real. It makes the documentary seem more believable as we see Michael Moore going step by step explaining what he is going to do. In a way, having him explaining this to us would make the viewer feel more safe, expecially when talking about a subject such as this.

4.Reflexive (awareness of the process)
This mode acknowledges the constructed nature of documentary and flaunts it conveying to people that it is not necessarily "truth" but a reconstruction of it. "A truth but not THE truth."

Biggie and Tupac is a documentary based on the lifes and deaths of both Biggie Smalls and Tupac Shakur. How they went from being close friends to meer enemies. This documentary shows you how the presenter goes form place to place, with his cameras, driving around in the car telling us what they are going to do next and then doing it, asking for people to interview. This makes it a reflexicve documentary as we are aware of the process of how they film the documentary. They use graphics and interviews with family members, archive footage from police tapes aswell as explaining where this came from. People would argue that this is more truthful than the last, because of the explanations of their recordings.

Nick Broomfield uses realismmainly in his documentary as all the facts he is giving are helping to make the documentary more real for the audience.

Again, having the makers explain what is going on would help to make the audience feel safe and would help them to believe that what they are seeing isn't fake or lies. However, as documentaries like this talk about events which happened in the past with people who have passed away, the viewers may feel that the reconstructions in the documentary aren't the actual truth, or the whole truth.

5.Performative (filmmaker as participant)
This mode of documentary emphasizes the dubjective nature of the documentarian as well as acknowledging the subjective reading of the audeince - notions of objectivity are replaced by evocation and affect.

Catfish is an example of a performative documentary. Some would argue whether this documentary is real or acted, however, this documentary has still 're-enacted' the story of what happened. They have used a lot of opinions in this documentary, which also makes it a subjective one, and the facts have been replaced with the idea of steering the audience to take on a certain opinion of one of the 'characters'. It has been filmed and edited in such a way that is emphasizes the emotional and social impact on the audience. It is also a performative documentary as the person who has made and presented this documentary, is one of the main people in it, almost like he his telling the story of what happend.
This is what makes the documentary more dramatised than anything else, it is made to give us a shock ending.

As this type of documentary isnt based on a true story, some people may feel scared about incidents like this. Although the documentary being from someones point of view, this doesnt mean its based on a true story. However, this being the case, some members of the audience may feel threatened by some of the images and information presented in this video.